Join Chalkbeat’s free weekly e-newsletter to maintain up with how schooling is altering throughout the U.S.
A number of state Head Begin associations and dad or mum teams are combating a Trump administration effort to bar undocumented kids from the federally funded Head Begin program.
The teams, that are represented by the American Civil Liberties Union, requested a federal district court docket on Tuesday to amend an April lawsuit they filed towards the Trump administration over Head Begin modifications. They wish to add a problem to the federal government’s July 14 directive calling for the exclusion of undocumented kids from this system.
Tuesday’s movement marks the second time the plaintiffs have sought to replace their lawsuit in an effort to maintain up with what they see as a collection of abrupt and dangerous modifications which might be chipping away on the 60-year-old program. The teams’ unique lawsuit got here after the Trump administration closed 5 regional Head Begin workplaces, reduce 60% of Head Begin workers, and banned federal grant recipients, together with Head Begin suppliers, from selling variety, fairness, inclusion, or accessibility.
Ming-Qi Chu, deputy director of the Ladies’s Rights Undertaking on the ACLU, mentioned the Trump administration’s July 14 directive represents one other step within the authorities technique to kill Head Begin by frequently weakening this system.
“The message of reserving Head Begin for U.S. residents is actually at odds with a core objective of Head Begin — to have the ability to serve immigrant communities,” she mentioned.
Whereas a July 10 press launch from the Division of Well being and Human Companies mentioned Head Begin can be “reserved for Americans any further,” federal officers later clarified that sure immigrants would nonetheless qualify, together with authorized everlasting residents, kids who’ve been granted asylum, refugees, and youngsters with humanitarian parole.
Chu mentioned the court docket hasn’t but dominated on whether or not the ACLU can amend the lawsuit to incorporate arguments towards the brand new federal directive, however mentioned she’s optimistic the court docket will enable it.
The plaintiffs within the case embrace Father or mother Voices Oakland, Household Ahead Oregon, and Head Begin associations from 4 states: Washington, Illinois, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin.
Head Begin supplies free little one care, preschool, and varied different providers to about 750,000 kids from low-income households yearly. Conservatives have criticized the protection internet program for years, however assaults have ramped up in recent times. Undertaking 2025, a conservative coverage agenda launched in 2023, known as for its elimination. In April, a leaked model of the president’s draft funds did the identical — although Trump backpedaled on that plan a number of weeks later.
Regardless of escaping the funds knife for now, Head Begin has felt the impression of non permanent funding freezes, complicated federal directives, and layoffs of federal Head Begin staff. Some Head Begin packages have closed and laid off staff, halting providers to a whole lot of kids and households.
The Trump administration’s July 14 directive, revealed a number of days after Division of Well being and Human Companies officers introduced the brand new coverage, is the newest wrench to hit Head Begin suppliers and households.
For many years, Head Begin was not thought of a “federal public profit” like Medicaid, SNAP, and Momentary Help for Needy Households — all of which aren’t out there to undocumented immigrants. The Trump administration has now reinterpreted the definition of federal public profit to incorporate Head Begin, basically shutting out undocumented kids.
Chu mentioned it’s the job of Congress, not the presidential administration, to find out whether or not Head Begin must be thought of a federal public profit. When Congress did outline the time period in a 1996 welfare reform regulation, it particularly cited “postsecondary schooling” as a federal public profit, however didn’t embrace early childhood or Okay-12 schooling.
Within the landmark 1982 Plyler v. Doe case, the U.S. Supreme Courtroom dominated that kids have a proper to a free public schooling no matter immigration standing, however that case centered on Okay-12 schooling.
The July 14 directive says the rule change aligns with a number of current Trump actions “that mirror the desire of the American those who aliens shouldn’t burden our public advantages system and that our public advantages system shouldn’t function a magnet for unlawful immigration.”
Apart from the definition of federal public advantages, Chu cited different issues with the brand new Head Begin coverage. By making it efficient instantly, the Trump administration disregarded key processes meant to delay rule modifications till the general public has an opportunity to remark and that require a radical cost-benefit evaluation, she mentioned.
“We all know that [the Health and Human Services Department] didn’t attempt to grapple in any respect with the big price this could have on immigrant households that relied on Head Begin for many years,” she mentioned.
It’s unclear what number of kids the brand new Trump administration rule might bar from Head Begin.
The federal directive states, “The Division anticipates that quite a few unqualified aliens will now not obtain advantages beneath Federally funded packages as a result of this discover.”
It’s not clear but whether or not all Head Begin suppliers must confirm a baby’s immigration standing earlier than enrolling them. Some Head Begin suppliers have pointed to language in federal regulation that exempts nonprofit charities from verifying the immigration standing of beneficiaries. Head Begin suppliers embrace non-public nonprofits in addition to college districts and different public entities. Nonetheless, the Well being and Human Companies Division has not but issued steerage on what suppliers can be requested to do.
Ann Schimke is a senior reporter at Chalkbeat, protecting early childhood points and early literacy. Contact Ann at aschimke@chalkbeat.org.
